Should board evaluation results ever be made public?
Board evaluation results should not generally be made public in full. The candid, individual-level feedback that makes a board evaluation genuinely useful depends on confidentiality: without it, directors are unlikely to engage openly, and the process loses its developmental value. That said, a degree of high-level disclosure is both expected and appropriate, particularly for listed companies. The questions below unpack where the line should be drawn and why it matters.
What information do board evaluations typically contain?
A board effectiveness evaluation typically contains assessments of how well the board functions as a collective, alongside feedback on individual directors‘ contributions, skills, and behaviours. The content spans board composition, dynamics, decision-making quality, committee effectiveness, the relationship with management, and strategic oversight, making it inherently sensitive material.
In practice, a thorough board evaluation will gather views on topics such as:
- The balance of skills, experience, and diversity on the board
- The quality of board dynamics and how constructively challenge is exercised
- The effectiveness of the Chair’s leadership
- How well the board manages its relationship with the CEO and senior management
- The adequacy of information provided to directors before meetings
- Individual director performance and engagement
- Committee effectiveness and reporting to the full board
Because evaluations include anonymous peer feedback and individual director assessments, the full dataset is far more granular and personal than most governance disclosures. This is precisely why the question of what, if anything, should be made public requires careful consideration.
What are the arguments for disclosing board evaluation results?
The primary argument for disclosing board evaluation results is accountability. Shareholders, investors, and other stakeholders have a legitimate interest in knowing whether the board is functioning effectively and taking concrete steps to improve. Transparency around the evaluation process signals that governance is taken seriously rather than treated as a compliance formality.
Disclosure can also serve as a credibility signal. When companies communicate the themes emerging from their evaluation and the actions being taken in response, it demonstrates that the process has produced genuine insight rather than a rubber-stamp outcome. Institutional investors in particular have become increasingly attentive to the quality of board evaluation disclosures, and vague or boilerplate statements attract scrutiny.
There is also an argument that public accountability creates healthy pressure. Knowing that some form of disclosure will follow can encourage boards to take the evaluation process more seriously, engage more honestly, and commit to follow-through on identified priorities. In this sense, the prospect of disclosure can reinforce the developmental rigour of the process itself.
What are the risks of making board evaluation results public?
The most significant risk of making board evaluation results public is that full disclosure undermines the confidentiality that makes honest evaluation possible. If directors believe their individual feedback or peer assessments will be shared externally, they are likely to moderate their responses, reducing the candour that produces actionable insight.
Beyond the chilling effect on participation, public disclosure of detailed evaluation findings creates several practical risks:
- Reputational exposure: Identified weaknesses, if disclosed in detail, can be used by activists, short-sellers, or media to construct damaging narratives that may not reflect the board’s actual trajectory.
- Legal and regulatory sensitivity: Detailed findings touching on individual directors could raise questions under data protection frameworks, particularly where named or identifiable feedback is involved.
- Distortion of the process: When evaluation outputs are written with public audiences in mind, they tend to become corporate communications exercises rather than genuine governance diagnostics.
- Competitive sensitivity: Findings related to strategic priorities, management relationships, or risk oversight may contain information that is commercially sensitive.
The result is a tension that governance professionals must navigate carefully: enough transparency to satisfy legitimate stakeholder expectations, without so much disclosure that the evaluation itself becomes compromised.
What do corporate governance codes say about board evaluation disclosure?
Most leading corporate governance codes require listed companies to report on whether a board evaluation has been conducted and to describe the process and outcomes at a high level, but they stop well short of requiring full disclosure of results. The UK Corporate Governance Code, for example, requires FTSE 350 companies to undertake an externally facilitated board evaluation at least every three years and to describe in the annual report how the evaluation was conducted and what actions have resulted.
The emphasis across codes is consistently on process transparency and outcome accountability rather than granular disclosure. Regulators and code bodies recognise that requiring detailed public disclosure would be counterproductive: it would incentivise boards to sanitise their evaluations rather than engage authentically.
In markets such as Germany, the Netherlands, and Switzerland, equivalent expectations apply under their respective governance frameworks, with similar logic: disclose that an evaluation occurred, describe the methodology, and outline the material findings and follow-up actions. The specifics of what constitutes adequate disclosure vary by jurisdiction and listing rules, which is why Company Secretaries and governance advisers must remain current with the applicable code requirements for their organisation.
What level of board evaluation detail should be disclosed publicly?
The appropriate level of public disclosure covers the process used, the broad themes identified, and the actions the board has committed to taking, but not individual director feedback, verbatim responses, or granular scoring data. This framing satisfies the accountability expectations of shareholders and governance codes without compromising the integrity of the evaluation itself.
In practice, a well-constructed public disclosure might include:
- Whether the evaluation was internal or externally facilitated, and by whom
- The methodology used (questionnaire, interviews, observation, or a combination)
- The scope of the review (full board, committees, individual directors)
- The principal areas of strength identified
- The key development priorities or areas for improvement
- Specific actions agreed and the expected timeframe for review
What should remain confidential includes individual director assessments, anonymised peer feedback, raw survey data, and any commentary on specific interpersonal dynamics or succession-related considerations. The distinction is between disclosing that the board has identified a need to strengthen its digital expertise, for instance, versus disclosing which director was assessed as lacking in that area.
Who should have access to board evaluation results?
Full board evaluation results should be accessible only to the board itself, typically through the Chair, the Company Secretary, and any external evaluation provider involved. Individual director reports should be shared with each director and the Chair, but not circulated more broadly. Regulators and auditors may have access where required by applicable rules, but this is the exception rather than the norm.
In practice, access should be structured around a clear need-to-know principle:
- The full board: Aggregated findings and collective themes, sufficient to inform discussion and action planning
- The Chair: Full results, including individual director assessments, to support development conversations and succession planning
- Individual directors: Their own personalised report, including peer feedback attributed only in aggregate
- The Company Secretary: Process management and record-keeping, with access appropriate to their coordination role
- External facilitator: Full data during the evaluation period, subject to confidentiality obligations
- Shareholders and the public: High-level process and outcome summary only, as described above
This tiered approach protects the candour of the process while ensuring that those with governance responsibility have the information they need to act on the findings.
How Better Boards supports board evaluation disclosure decisions
Deciding what to disclose (and to whom) is easier when the evaluation itself is structured to separate aggregated insights from individual feedback from the outset. Better Boards‘ board evaluation platform is designed with exactly this in mind, giving governance leaders the tools to manage access, confidentiality, and reporting at every level.
- Individualised director reports kept separate from board-level summaries
- ISO 27001-certified data security, so sensitive evaluation data is protected throughout
- Benchmarked, anonymised insights that can be shared publicly without compromising individual confidentiality
- Support for both internal and externally facilitated evaluations, aligned with applicable governance code requirements
- Structured outputs that make it straightforward to produce annual report disclosures at the appropriate level of detail
If you are reviewing your approach to board evaluation disclosure or considering how to structure your next evaluation, explore our board evaluation software or discuss your requirements with our team.
Ähnliche Artikel
- What technology tools support modern board evaluation processes?
- How often should a board of directors complete a formal evaluation?
- How does a board evaluation differ across sectors like nonprofit and corporate?
- What is a third-party board evaluation and when should you use one?
- How do you evaluate a newly formed board in its first year?

